News RSS Feed


Swindon Advertiser newsroom Swindon Advertiser Loyalty Card Swindon Talent 09 Adver Mobile Race For Life Repatriations through Wootton Bassett

Got a story? EMAIL US, call us on 01793 501806 or text us at 80360, starting your message with 'SWINDON NEWS'

Swindon's A&E is the best in the country

11:20am Thursday 3rd July 2008

comment Comments (24)   Have your say »


THE accident and emergency department at the Great Western Hospital is officially the most efficient in the country.

This was the verdict of the Strategic Health Authority on figures for the last three months.

To meet Government targets hospitals must deal with 98 per cent of emergency patients within four hours.

GWH has been constantly above this and, for the last three months, 99.74 per cent of patients have been seen within four hours.

Of those 60 per cent are seen in under two hours and, over several weeks, the hospital had no cases waiting over the time.

Dr Alf Troughton, the medical director of the hospital, said: "This improvement is down to Dr Kash Aujla, consultant in the emergency department, and all his staff who have worked incredibly hard to transform the quality of treatment."

The hospital made the leap from the 124th ranking to the top spot in just a year.

The waiting figures are based on when a patient has passed through the emergency system, meaning they have been assessed, treated and admitted as an in-patient or treated and sent home.

On an average week the department will deal with about 1,200 patients a week.

Half of those will be suffering from minor injuries and the other half will be people who come in on stretchers with major injuries.

Dr Aujla said: "It's been hard work to get to this level and now our task is to maintain this performance."

Hospital emergency departments are dependent on many factors to make these figures, such as delayed transfers of care within the hospital - patients who are in hospital but are unable to leave because outside care has not been made available.

Dr Troughton added: "This is something the A and E department are set, but I think to do it the whole hospital has to work together - we have to have to have an empty bed on the ward for a patient to be admitted."

Dr Troughton said one factor in their success was that surgeons and specialists were much quicker at coming to patients down in A and E, partly because of progress chasers employed to ensure the department keeps to time.

The hospital has also re-examined its processes to see if it could be more efficient and increase the number of nurses in the department.

"I think people have genuinely worked much harder everybody has seen the importance of it and has pulled out all the stops," said Dr Troughton.

"If you thought you had to wait for six hours you'd be pretty miserable, so to know it will be done within four hours is better.

"It's a sensible target that most members of the public would agree was important."


Your Say YourSwindon Advertiser

Meldrews Dad, Wroughton says...
11:36am Thu 3 Jul 08

Yet another "target" driven award. Tell the truth about GWH it should be closed, staff retrained and only opened again when it can offer a decent service to the population.

I had the misfortune to have to use A and E once, four years ago, and suffered an incompetent diagnosis, a nurse taking blood without gloves, an arrogance that was beyond belief and suprise when I walked out absolutely disgusted.

Never again do I set foot in GWH as a patient.

LordBelacqua, Swindon says...
11:40am Thu 3 Jul 08

4 years ago.

The figures have been taken over the last 3 months.

You don't think it might just have improved since then?

Jacko, swindon area says...
11:47am Thu 3 Jul 08

Meldrews Dad wrote:
Yet another "target" driven award. Tell the truth about GWH it should be closed, staff retrained and only opened again when it can offer a decent service to the population. I had the misfortune to have to use A and E once, four years ago, and suffered an incompetent diagnosis, a nurse taking blood without gloves, an arrogance that was beyond belief and suprise when I walked out absolutely disgusted. Never again do I set foot in GWH as a patient.
I understand exactlly how you feel. Your lucky to survive.

Frontier(s), says...
11:51am Thu 3 Jul 08

Credit where it's due, this performance in the A&E department does seem very good.

It'd be interesting to see the figures for the rest of the hospital as a whole.

Loft Conversions, Swindon says...
11:51am Thu 3 Jul 08

You'd better wear an ID bracelet then, MD, stating that if you are involved in a serious accident you'd rather be taken to the JR in Oxford rather than 10 minutes up the road to the GWH.

Personally I've always had top class service there, as has everyone I've spoken to.

Dosomethingmutley, Hanger 14 Swindon says...
12:03pm Thu 3 Jul 08

I have always been treated professionally, promptly and have only praise for the GWH on the many occasions I have had to be admitted.
My wife has just had a serious operation and her care and treatment have been first rate.
My daughter had complications during her recent pregnancy and again, the treatment, care and staff were superb.
Enough said!!

Casual Observer, Swindon says...
12:05pm Thu 3 Jul 08

I've also generally had excellent service but the earlier point about arrogance is valid for some of the staff.

Dealing with the general public is never going to be sweetness and light all the time but some staff show a staggering beligerance no matter how nice you are to them. Always in full view of the many signs warning the public not to abuse the staff.

Sometimes I honestly think they ask for it.

PaulD, says...
12:08pm Thu 3 Jul 08

a nurse taking blood without gloves


You can always ask a nurse or doctor to wear or change their gloves.


Frontier(s), says...
12:51pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Sometimes I honestly think they ask for it.


It's a bit like the police. They are forever begging for help from the 'community' but then always insist on speaking to law-abiding people as if they're either murderers or just plain poo on their shoes.

Adder, Swindon says...
12:56pm Thu 3 Jul 08

These targets have only been met beacause the A&E Unit delays admissions by queuing up ambulances at the emergency entrance until they know they can get the patient registered and dealt with within the 4 hours. When my old chap was rushed up there a while ago we were sat in the car park in the ambulance for ages before admittance.

Frontier(s), says...
1:08pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Ahhh, very clever. I can quite believe that Adder.

That's the problem with government targets - the people who are drafted in to 'meet' them know how to get round them.

katyp333, stoke-on-trent says...
1:16pm Thu 3 Jul 08

My little boy was 3 when he was treated in the A & E 2 years ago for a broken arm and dislocated elbow. The doctor's were fantastic and one of them even bought my son a cuddly toy from the shop for being so brave. They were amazing in such traumatic circumstances, no complaints whatsoever.

roy bezzant, swindon says...
1:47pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Frontier(s).You appear to want to kknock all the public services.I suggest you aim your bullets at thier masters the government and not the people who try and thier jobs albeit under the constaints the government put on them.

Bea, Swindon says...
3:04pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Use Cirencester hospital wait no more than 5 minutes see a doctor straight away. I used it when my daughter cut her eye open on a childs slide.

They even had a plastic surgeon available there when we got there to make sure she didn't damage it too much and need further surgery.

A fantastic hospital. Use GWH - not a chance.

swindon1983, Swindon says...
3:43pm Thu 3 Jul 08

I have this suggestion, lets all go private, pay through the nose in monthly fees and never moan! Yeah right! I am happy with waiting at any hospital! It's free to use at source! I went to a hospital in the USA after an injury and the insurance company paid yet the wait was 3 hours! Lets stop moaning and thank the government and the staff of the hospital for being open 24 hours a day! If you want to travel to a different hospital so be it, maybe one that might only see 100 patients a day, but remember Swindon is big and we are so so so lucky not to have an old hospital like BRI!

Al Smith, Swindon, UK says...
4:34pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Bea - did you have a bad experience at GWH, or do you by any chances think the occasional bad story is representative? I've heard nothing but positive reports from friends who HAVE been treated there - I consider them to be more representative than a web discussion or a sensationalist newspaper headline.

wendy, swindon says...
4:34pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Everyone's opinions will differ dramatically on this one. Some people have been lucky and received dignity/respect/good treatment and friendly staff, others experience has been quite different including mine and it would be impossible for people to agree on this one, it is completely dependent on the experience you have had personally, mine was very unpleasant, but I'm glad many people have a good experience there.

sianw50, calne says...
5:17pm Thu 3 Jul 08

i went in when i had a burst cyst
i had a drip put in and the had an anti sickness drug put in that and it was so painful i screamed. then then put saline in after about 10 mins i told someone that it was agony and i was told it was saline working its way through i told 2 people and they said same thing
i was then left for 2 hours while my arm went dead and was swollen to 3 times its size as i was attached to bed i couldn't move and after 2 hours a nurse heard me crying saw my arm and got someone else who said
" oh that shouldn't be like that" and then took the drip out
2 hours later the docs were looking in a medical book to see if it was ok to put the drug in my arm and not my vein and it was a few days before my arm went down.
i had no apologes or anything

Jacko, swindon area says...
5:35pm Thu 3 Jul 08

sianw50 wrote:
i went in when i had a burst cyst i had a drip put in and the had an anti sickness drug put in that and it was so painful i screamed. then then put saline in after about 10 mins i told someone that it was agony and i was told it was saline working its way through i told 2 people and they said same thing i was then left for 2 hours while my arm went dead and was swollen to 3 times its size as i was attached to bed i couldn't move and after 2 hours a nurse heard me crying saw my arm and got someone else who said " oh that shouldn't be like that" and then took the drip out 2 hours later the docs were looking in a medical book to see if it was ok to put the drug in my arm and not my vein and it was a few days before my arm went down. i had no apologes or anything
Sounds like you have a perfectly good case for negligence

Al Smith, Swindon, UK says...
8:49pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Jacko, how exactly will suing help improve things? By taking away money that should be being spent on patients? I think "robbing Peter to pay Paul" describes the situation pretty well.

Wendy, I see you use the word "some", I would say "most" people have had an OK experience. It's just that someone who has had a bad experience will shout about it far more than someone whose experience was fine or brilliant.

Captain Sensible, Near Swindon says...
7:49am Fri 4 Jul 08

I dont see how waiting up to 4 hours for treatment can be classed as something to shout about, its nothing short of a disgrace.

Frontier(s), says...
9:00am Fri 4 Jul 08

roy bezzant wrote:
Frontier(s).You appear to want to kknock all the public services.I suggest you aim your bullets at thier masters the government and not the people who try and thier jobs albeit under the constaints the government put on them.
Oh, Roy, you clearly don't read my posts very often.

I have no doubt whatsoever who is ultimately to blame for the state of our vastly expensive public services.

However, you can't deny that some civil servants (police, council officials etc.) don't make their lives any easier by generally being as condescending as they possibly can.

mr, swindon says...
9:00am Fri 4 Jul 08

I SEE NO MENTION OF AAU THAT A&E PASS MOST OF THEIR PATIENTS ONTO. WITHOUT THEM THE PLACE WOULD FALL APART. THEY WORK 13 HR SHIFTS AND ARE SHORT STAFF BUT NOONE AT THE HOSPITAL KNOWS HOW TO LOOK AFTER THEM

HER_IN_DOORS, Swindon says...
8:08am Sun 6 Jul 08

If you have a "minor injury" then you expect to wait whilst life threatening injuries are treated. How would you feel to be told please don't die - Mr X has a cut on his leg and got here first. Regarding the ambulances in the car park this is to ensure that the patient has the best care by trained paramedics rather than being put on a trolley in the corridor. Have you never queued in Tesco when its busy - same principle. I have seen both sides of A&E both as a patient and as an employee. The staff have to put up with a lot of ignorance and general bad manners and thats not considered abuse. If people only used A&E as an ACCIDENT AND EMERGENCY UNIT and not an out of hours help desk then waiting times would be drastically reduced. Many a time I have seen the unit full of VERY minor injuries that could have been treated at home or referred to a doctor the next day.
I have always had excellent service from the staff but then I suppose I understand their frustrations and always have a kind word and a smile. They are only doing their job to the best of their ability. I also noted on the last visit that good english was widly spoken - now that is an improvement!!

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »