News RSS Feed


Email us your story, call 01793 501806 or text 80360, starting your message with 'SWINDON NEWS'


Police changes are under fire


SWINDON councillors have criticised Government plans to shake-up the policing in England and Wales.

Coun Brian Ford (Con), who is vice-chairman of Wiltshire Police Authority, said he was ‘totally opposed’ to the plans.

And Swindon council’s Labour group leader, Coun Derique Montaut, called the move ‘unnecessary’ and said it risked ‘politicising’ the police force.

Home Secretary Theresa May announced on Monday that police authorities would be scrapped and instead from May 2012 elected police commissioners would have the power to hire and fire chief constables. People would also be able to vote for locally-elected officials to oversee each police force.

Wiltshire Police Authority is made up of 17 members. Six councillors are appointed by Wiltshire Council; three councillors appointed by Swindon council and eight independent members (one of whom is a magistrate) .

Coun Montaut, a former member of Wiltshire Police Authority, said: “It is the Swindon Labour group’s belief that politicising the police force would be wrong for Swindon and wrong for the country.

“What these proposals mean for Swindon is that we will have an elected police commissioner for just Wiltshire, who will be sat in Devizes concentrating on rural issues that face the rest of the county.

“Of course, Swindon has a completely different set of problems to Wiltshire but we will not be able to get our voices heard because the police commissioner will be representing the whole of the county.

“During a period of low crime my fear is that these proposals will lead to the police taking their eye off the ball in thinking about how they can maintain and even further reduce current levels in crime.”

He said that during his time on Wiltshire Police Authority he was able to see first hand how the police could be held to account on behalf of the people of Swindon in ‘a non-politicised way’.

Coun Ford said he also believed the proposals were flawed.

He said: “I’m totally opposed to the Conservative proposals and I was actually part of a delegation of a dozen members of the Association of Police Authorities who went to Portcullis House about 18 months ago to see the then shadow Home Secretary and Police Minister and spent three hours arguing very strongly against having Police Commissioners.

“I find it difficult to understand how one person can do what 17 are at the moment and if one person does do the job they will probably get additional officer assistance which will cost money.

“I think it could end up costing the country tens of millions.”

Wiltshire Police declined to comment on the proposals.

Comments(6)

The Real Librarian says...
9:56pm Thu 29 Jul 10

And Swindon council’s Labour group leader, Coun Derique Montaut, called the move ‘unnecessary’ and said it risked ‘politicising’ the police force.
Coun Montaut, a former member of Wiltshire Police Authority, said: “It is the Swindon Labour group’s belief that politicising the police force would be wrong for Swindon and wrong for the country. "
.
.
The Police Force was politicised a ong time ago. When Sir Ian Blair (no relation,) worked hand in glove with T'other Blair to carry out Labour Party wishes.
.
Did Coun Montaut object to this? If not, why not?

The Real Librarian says...
9:58pm Thu 29 Jul 10

Like Coun Ford, I am opposed to the idea, but for different reasons.
.
There is no point in electing someone to work with the Police in this way, unless they are in charge. If they are not, the Police will just go their own sweet way, as usual.
.
If we want democratc control of the Police then we should elect Chief Constables.

swindon_mini says...
1:41am Fri 30 Jul 10

So his concerns are nothing to do with the £195000 its members drew last year? That is around £11500 for each member.

politicrat says...
9:30am Fri 30 Jul 10

Elected police like in the USA is an essential process in making the police more accountable and also connect the police with the community it is supposed to protect.
Politicians do not like citizens getting involved because it shortcuts their clientelism business, from which they make an extraordinary amount of money.
Next step would be for judges to be elected
Then and only then we might have a justice and police working for the good of the people instead of the State and its targets.

Bobfm says...
9:37am Fri 30 Jul 10

The Real Librarian, electing Chief Constables has long been UKIP's policy for the reasons you outline. It would return the 'policing with consent' formally the main plank of UK policing.

adsinibiza says...
11:48am Fri 30 Jul 10

As a Police Authority raises tax it is only right and proper that it should be directly accountable to the people that pay those taxes. The only way to acheive this is for the Police Authority to be directly elected - which it is not. Changing to a system of an elected Police Commisioner (or Cheif Constable) would acheive this as well as making the police more accountable to those that they serve and who pay their wages as Politicrat suggests.

Perhaps the reason that the Police do not like these proposals is that they are going to have to get out of their cars a little more often and do the job that the public wants and pays them to do!

I would also go along with Politicrat's suggestions about diretly elected Judges - that would soon put a stop to the soft sentencing that lets criminals off the hook all to often.

Both are long over due!


Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses